Five Point Somone or 3 Idiots: Which is better?

We have heard about Five Point Someone being the basis of 3 Idiots and the 3 Idiots controversy. But which is better, Five Point Someone or 3 Idiots. Bollywood Trends readers please have your say on which is actually better:

Meanwhile, though 3 Idiots is a good movie, there are some scenes which are questionable
1. Kambakkht Ishq was criticized by the high-brow elite critics for having toilet humor in the form of a small fart scene, whereas there are too many toilet jokes and crude humor in 3 Idiots. Were they needed?

2. The laughable 'Chamatkar Balatkaar' scene is slapstick funny no doubt, but we doubt whether people would have thought it to be 'classy' if it was in a Priyadarshan or David Dhawan movie.

3. Raj Kumar Hirani is getting repetitive and his style of film making is getting cliched. There are similar ragging scenes in both Munnabhai MBBS and 3 Idiots.The scene where Rancho says he wants to give a demo to Pia(Kareena Kapoor) about his stupid fiancé is quite similar to Sanjay Dutt in Lage Raho Munnabhai asking girl to do a ‘demo’ on the ideal man of her dreams. He says that if the man whistles to the waiter, he is not worth being a life partner. Parallel are there, for sure. In all three movies, Munnabhai MBBS, Lagey Raho Munnabhai or 3 Idiots there is a common element of a person who wants to 'melt the heart of the other person with love and affection'. I would rather appreciate Mani Rathnam whose Anjali was so different from Bombay and whose Velu Nayakan was much different from Guru.

That apart, in isolation, 3 Idiots is a good movie but it is definitely comparable with Hirani's other two ventures, which were far better.

Compared to this, the book Five Point Someone was very original and just had one 'Dil Chahta Hai' like scene where the friend Alok seperates from the other two. Rest everything in the book was original.