3 Idiots Mistakes and MNIK Georgia Hurricane Scene

The debate about whether My Name is Khan or 3 Idiots is better, seems to be an endless discussion that is being fiercely contested in Bollywood Trends and many other blogs and sites. Here are the points that make 3 Idiots an average film, at least compared to Aamir's movies like Jo Jeeta Wohi Sikandar, Taare Zameen Par, Rang De Basanti and Dil Chahta Hai

Here are the points where 3 Idiots sucks

1. Mona Singh's delivery scene may look good but it is long-draw and disgusting in a way. Kareena directing Aamir over the web came to use a vaccum cleaner as a suction to get the baby out.

2. Kareena walking out of her marriage for the second time. Haven't we seen like this before? That is a pure filmy scene

3. The clash of view points between Aamir Khan and Boman Irani has been seen in the Munnabhai franchise between Sanjay Dutt and Boman Irani

4. Things like 'follow your dreams' are things that we already know. What is so great in it?

5. Frequent dropping of pants, pissing and farting-3 Idiots is toilet humor at its worst. If this film had a Govinda or Akshay Kumar in it with David Dhawan or Priyadarshan directing, we would have critics and people smirking.

6. The Javed Jaffery twist at the interval, was that even needed?

7. Sharman Joshi's mom in the movie is bothered about Maruti Car as dowry. That is taken from 5 Point Someone point-blank. You could have at least said a better thing, Maruti Car is so very 90s!

A lot of people feel that the hurricane scene in My Name is Khan was not necessary. They ask what was the US government doing, why did they need Mr. Khan to save the town? But we need to know that the movie had to bring out the humane side in Khan. Rizvan Khan does not go to save Georgia, he remembers that two of his friends Mama Jenny and her son Funny Hair Joel are stuck there, so he makes it a point to rescue them. Wouldn't we do it if we were in Rizvan's place? He ends up helping other people who had taken shelter in the church. So we wouldn't really call it an exaggerated scene, at least it doesnt look too filmy as some of the 3 Idiots scenes mentioned up there